{"case_version":"wh-orderpicking.v1","summary":[{"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","replications":10,"valid":10,"failed":0,"distance_mean_m":2329.8,"distance_sd_m":183.5639761318471,"distance_min_m":2064.0,"distance_max_m":2560.0,"makespan_mean_s":2258.899999999987,"makespan_sd_s":177.0344390015587,"makespan_min_s":1986.999999999973,"makespan_max_s":2484.333333333334,"labour_mean_s":2258.899999999987,"labour_sd_s":177.0344390015587,"labour_min_s":1986.999999999973,"labour_max_s":2484.333333333334,"runtime_mean_s":0.0037978606999985232,"units_mean":105.8},{"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","replications":10,"valid":10,"failed":0,"distance_mean_m":1949.0,"distance_sd_m":145.71585744561608,"distance_min_m":1763.0,"distance_max_m":2126.0,"makespan_mean_s":1941.566666666648,"makespan_sd_s":143.99125916543875,"makespan_min_s":1748.1666666666529,"makespan_max_s":2121.8333333333103,"labour_mean_s":1941.566666666648,"labour_sd_s":143.99125916543875,"labour_min_s":1748.1666666666529,"labour_max_s":2121.8333333333103,"runtime_mean_s":0.0066574625999948015,"units_mean":105.8},{"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","replications":10,"valid":10,"failed":0,"distance_mean_m":761.7,"distance_sd_m":74.46408530291633,"distance_min_m":630.0,"distance_max_m":849.0,"makespan_mean_s":952.1500000000044,"makespan_sd_s":88.63597526462551,"makespan_min_s":792.0000000000019,"makespan_max_s":1058.5000000000045,"labour_mean_s":952.1500000000044,"labour_sd_s":88.63597526462551,"labour_min_s":792.0000000000019,"labour_max_s":1058.5000000000045,"runtime_mean_s":0.0030374632999951245,"units_mean":105.8},{"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","replications":10,"valid":10,"failed":0,"distance_mean_m":693.1,"distance_sd_m":61.37217972701022,"distance_min_m":576.0,"distance_max_m":781.0,"makespan_mean_s":894.983333333337,"makespan_sd_s":78.56794849596353,"makespan_min_s":747.0000000000014,"makespan_max_s":1001.8333333333386,"labour_mean_s":894.983333333337,"labour_sd_s":78.56794849596353,"labour_min_s":747.0000000000014,"labour_max_s":1001.8333333333386,"runtime_mean_s":0.11063612069999636,"units_mean":105.8},{"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","replications":10,"valid":10,"failed":0,"distance_mean_m":693.1,"distance_sd_m":61.37217972701022,"distance_min_m":576.0,"distance_max_m":781.0,"makespan_mean_s":337.9166666666664,"makespan_sd_s":17.286841138368978,"makespan_min_s":297.8333333333333,"makespan_max_s":356.66666666666623,"labour_mean_s":894.9833333333331,"labour_sd_s":78.56794849596216,"labour_min_s":747.0000000000003,"labour_max_s":1001.8333333333326,"runtime_mean_s":0.00022211719999347678,"units_mean":105.8},{"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","replications":10,"valid":10,"failed":0,"distance_mean_m":693.1,"distance_sd_m":61.37217972701022,"distance_min_m":576.0,"distance_max_m":781.0,"makespan_mean_s":322.53333333333325,"makespan_sd_s":13.374888946117855,"makespan_min_s":297.8333333333333,"makespan_max_s":339.4999999999998,"labour_mean_s":894.9833333333332,"labour_sd_s":78.56794849596213,"labour_min_s":747.0000000000005,"labour_max_s":1001.8333333333325,"runtime_mean_s":0.00023756180000020777,"units_mean":105.8}],"per_replications":[{"seed":1,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2498.0,"labour_s":2423.6666666666615,"makespan_s":2423.6666666666615,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0040620560000093064},{"seed":1,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2126.0,"labour_s":2113.666666666649,"makespan_s":2113.666666666649,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0074879089999910775},{"seed":1,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":839.0,"labour_s":1041.1666666666727,"makespan_s":1041.1666666666727,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0032018660000119326},{"seed":1,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":746.0,"labour_s":963.6666666666717,"makespan_s":963.6666666666717,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.10153634199997441},{"seed":1,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":746.0,"labour_s":963.666666666666,"makespan_s":356.66666666666623,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00023929500000008375},{"seed":1,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":746.0,"labour_s":963.6666666666665,"makespan_s":327.16666666666663,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00023192099999391758},{"seed":2,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2168.0,"labour_s":2136.6666666666433,"makespan_s":2136.6666666666433,"picked_units":110,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.003646903999992901},{"seed":2,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":1793.0,"labour_s":1824.1666666666522,"makespan_s":1824.1666666666522,"picked_units":110,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.006652293999991343},{"seed":2,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":769.0,"labour_s":970.8333333333379,"makespan_s":970.8333333333379,"picked_units":110,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0031914569999855757},{"seed":2,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":699.0,"labour_s":912.5000000000039,"makespan_s":912.5000000000039,"picked_units":110,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.12243570499998668},{"seed":2,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":699.0,"labour_s":912.4999999999994,"makespan_s":333.6666666666663,"picked_units":110,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00024499599999217025},{"seed":2,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":699.0,"labour_s":912.5,"makespan_s":310.3333333333333,"picked_units":110,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0002473300000076506},{"seed":3,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2303.0,"labour_s":2216.1666666666515,"makespan_s":2216.1666666666515,"picked_units":99,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.004127267000001211},{"seed":3,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":1887.0,"labour_s":1869.4999999999832,"makespan_s":1869.4999999999832,"picked_units":99,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.00620985099999416},{"seed":3,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":690.0,"labour_s":872.0000000000031,"makespan_s":872.0000000000031,"picked_units":99,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.0028461139999933494},{"seed":3,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":646.0,"labour_s":835.3333333333356,"makespan_s":835.3333333333356,"picked_units":99,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.09803279499999462},{"seed":3,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":646.0,"labour_s":835.3333333333331,"makespan_s":336.16666666666646,"picked_units":99,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.00020498099999599617},{"seed":3,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":646.0,"labour_s":835.3333333333328,"makespan_s":336.16666666666646,"picked_units":99,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.00020444999998403546},{"seed":4,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2264.0,"labour_s":2198.666666666645,"makespan_s":2198.666666666645,"picked_units":104,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.003610646999987921},{"seed":4,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":1911.0,"labour_s":1904.49999999998,"makespan_s":1904.49999999998,"picked_units":104,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.006667411999984552},{"seed":4,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":793.0,"labour_s":972.8333333333384,"makespan_s":972.8333333333384,"picked_units":104,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0032246289999875444},{"seed":4,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":684.0,"labour_s":882.0000000000034,"makespan_s":882.0000000000034,"picked_units":104,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.11977707500000179},{"seed":4,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":684.0,"labour_s":882.0000000000001,"makespan_s":324.1666666666665,"picked_units":104,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00021616199998675256},{"seed":4,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":684.0,"labour_s":882.0000000000001,"makespan_s":324.1666666666665,"picked_units":104,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0002186670000128288},{"seed":5,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2089.0,"labour_s":2019.8333333333042,"makespan_s":2019.8333333333042,"picked_units":93,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.003453143000001546},{"seed":5,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":1763.0,"labour_s":1748.1666666666529,"makespan_s":1748.1666666666529,"picked_units":93,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0062220039999942856},{"seed":5,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":674.0,"labour_s":840.6666666666702,"makespan_s":840.6666666666702,"picked_units":93,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.002685975999980883},{"seed":5,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":628.0,"labour_s":802.3333333333362,"makespan_s":802.3333333333362,"picked_units":93,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.09114542399998982},{"seed":5,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":628.0,"labour_s":802.333333333333,"makespan_s":338.3333333333329,"picked_units":93,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.00019878000000517204},{"seed":5,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":628.0,"labour_s":802.3333333333337,"makespan_s":306.66666666666674,"picked_units":93,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.00023897399998418223},{"seed":6,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2560.0,"labour_s":2484.333333333334,"makespan_s":2484.333333333334,"picked_units":117,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.00393936699998676},{"seed":6,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2125.0,"labour_s":2121.8333333333103,"makespan_s":2121.8333333333103,"picked_units":117,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.006867454000001771},{"seed":6,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":849.0,"labour_s":1058.5000000000045,"makespan_s":1058.5000000000045,"picked_units":117,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0033439999999984593},{"seed":6,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":781.0,"labour_s":1001.8333333333386,"makespan_s":1001.8333333333386,"picked_units":117,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.13063584799999717},{"seed":6,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":781.0,"labour_s":1001.8333333333326,"makespan_s":350.3333333333328,"picked_units":117,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00023715099999321865},{"seed":6,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":781.0,"labour_s":1001.8333333333325,"makespan_s":339.4999999999998,"picked_units":117,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00028241500001513486},{"seed":7,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2522.0,"labour_s":2437.6666666666656,"makespan_s":2437.6666666666656,"picked_units":112,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0040329020000058335},{"seed":7,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2064.0,"labour_s":2055.999999999976,"makespan_s":2055.999999999976,"picked_units":112,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.006892910999994228},{"seed":7,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":756.0,"labour_s":966.0000000000047,"makespan_s":966.0000000000047,"picked_units":112,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.002995040999991261},{"seed":7,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":710.0,"labour_s":927.6666666666703,"makespan_s":927.6666666666703,"picked_units":112,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.09872439100001884},{"seed":7,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":710.0,"labour_s":927.6666666666667,"makespan_s":339.16666666666646,"picked_units":112,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00021883699997715667},{"seed":7,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":710.0,"labour_s":927.6666666666667,"makespan_s":326.6666666666666,"picked_units":112,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0002563070000007883},{"seed":8,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2064.0,"labour_s":1986.999999999973,"makespan_s":1986.999999999973,"picked_units":89,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.003596600999998145},{"seed":8,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":1791.0,"labour_s":1759.4999999999852,"makespan_s":1759.4999999999852,"picked_units":89,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.00616619999999557},{"seed":8,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":630.0,"labour_s":792.0000000000019,"makespan_s":792.0000000000019,"picked_units":89,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.0025859310000271307},{"seed":8,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":576.0,"labour_s":747.0000000000014,"makespan_s":747.0000000000014,"picked_units":89,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.12646730699998443},{"seed":8,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":576.0,"labour_s":747.0000000000003,"makespan_s":297.8333333333333,"picked_units":89,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.0001916669999957321},{"seed":8,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":576.0,"labour_s":747.0000000000005,"makespan_s":297.8333333333333,"picked_units":89,"orders_completed":30,"tours":5,"runtime_s":0.00022831499998687832},{"seed":9,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2488.0,"labour_s":2400.3333333333344,"makespan_s":2400.3333333333344,"picked_units":109,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0037679890000106298},{"seed":9,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2109.0,"labour_s":2084.4999999999795,"makespan_s":2084.4999999999795,"picked_units":109,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0068513939999945705},{"seed":9,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":790.0,"labour_s":985.3333333333386,"makespan_s":985.3333333333386,"picked_units":109,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0031221079999852464},{"seed":9,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":732.0,"labour_s":937.0000000000042,"makespan_s":937.0000000000042,"picked_units":109,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.09302576199999635},{"seed":9,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":732.0,"labour_s":936.9999999999998,"makespan_s":351.9999999999998,"picked_units":109,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00024018700000283388},{"seed":9,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":732.0,"labour_s":937.0,"makespan_s":325.6666666666665,"picked_units":109,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00024052800000617935},{"seed":10,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2342.0,"labour_s":2284.6666666666547,"makespan_s":2284.6666666666547,"picked_units":111,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0037417309999909776},{"seed":10,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":1921.0,"labour_s":1933.8333333333126,"makespan_s":1933.8333333333126,"picked_units":111,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.006557197000006454},{"seed":10,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":827.0,"labour_s":1022.1666666666721,"makespan_s":1022.1666666666721,"picked_units":111,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.003177510999989863},{"seed":10,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":729.0,"labour_s":940.5000000000043,"makespan_s":940.5000000000043,"picked_units":111,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.12458055800001944},{"seed":10,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":729.0,"labour_s":940.5,"makespan_s":350.83333333333303,"picked_units":111,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0002291159999856518},{"seed":10,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":729.0,"labour_s":940.4999999999998,"makespan_s":331.1666666666666,"picked_units":111,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00022671100001048217}],"illustrative":{"single_s_shape":"single-s-shape-seed1.json","single_optimal":"single-optimal-seed1.json","batch_seed":"batch-seed-seed1.json","batch_savings":"batch-savings-seed1.json","schedule_list":"schedule-list-seed1.json","schedule_lpt":"schedule-lpt-seed1.json"},"seed1":[{"seed":1,"scenario":"single_s_shape","routing":"s_shape","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2498.0,"labour_s":2423.6666666666615,"makespan_s":2423.6666666666615,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0040620560000093064},{"seed":1,"scenario":"single_optimal","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"single_order","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":2126.0,"labour_s":2113.666666666649,"makespan_s":2113.666666666649,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":30,"runtime_s":0.0074879089999910775},{"seed":1,"scenario":"batch_seed","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"seed","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":839.0,"labour_s":1041.1666666666727,"makespan_s":1041.1666666666727,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0032018660000119326},{"seed":1,"scenario":"batch_savings","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":746.0,"labour_s":963.6666666666717,"makespan_s":963.6666666666717,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.10153634199997441},{"seed":1,"scenario":"schedule_list","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"list","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":746.0,"labour_s":963.666666666666,"makespan_s":356.66666666666623,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00023929500000008375},{"seed":1,"scenario":"schedule_lpt","routing":"ratliff_rosenthal","batching":"time_savings","scheduling":"lpt","status":"ok","error":"","distance_m":746.0,"labour_s":963.6666666666665,"makespan_s":327.16666666666663,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.00023192099999391758}],"worked":{"distance_m":12.0,"travel_s":10.0,"picking_s":6.0,"duration_s":16.0,"picked_units":2,"orders_completed":2,"milestones":["F6","A6_01","F6","F7","A7_03","F7","F6"],"path":["F6","A6_01","F6","F7","A7_01","A7_02","A7_03","A7_02","A7_01","F7","F6"],"orders":[{"order_id":"W01","items":[{"sku":"demo-a","slot":"A6_L_01","quantity":1,"line_id":"L01"}],"size":1},{"order_id":"W02","items":[{"sku":"demo-b","slot":"A7_R_03","quantity":1,"line_id":"L01"}],"size":1}],"replay":"tiny-worked.json"},"sensitivity":[{"capacity":10,"seed":1,"distance_m":1240.0,"labour_s":1375.333333333329,"makespan_s":1375.333333333329,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":12,"runtime_s":0.004544312999996691},{"capacity":20,"seed":1,"distance_m":839.0,"labour_s":1041.1666666666727,"makespan_s":1041.1666666666727,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":6,"runtime_s":0.0026219060000016725},{"capacity":30,"seed":1,"distance_m":637.0,"labour_s":872.8333333333364,"makespan_s":872.8333333333364,"picked_units":114,"orders_completed":30,"tours":4,"runtime_s":0.001837617999996155}],"figures":{"single":"route-single.svg","batch":"route-batch.svg","schedule":"schedule.svg","comparison":"comparison.svg"},"output_dir":"tutorial-results","paired_comparisons":[{"seed":1,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2498.0,"alternative_value":2126.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-372.0},{"seed":2,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2168.0,"alternative_value":1793.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-375.0},{"seed":3,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2303.0,"alternative_value":1887.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-416.0},{"seed":4,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2264.0,"alternative_value":1911.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-353.0},{"seed":5,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2089.0,"alternative_value":1763.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-326.0},{"seed":6,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2560.0,"alternative_value":2125.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-435.0},{"seed":7,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2522.0,"alternative_value":2064.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-458.0},{"seed":8,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2064.0,"alternative_value":1791.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-273.0},{"seed":9,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2488.0,"alternative_value":2109.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-379.0},{"seed":10,"baseline":"single_s_shape","alternative":"single_optimal","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":2342.0,"alternative_value":1921.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-421.0},{"seed":1,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":839.0,"alternative_value":746.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-93.0},{"seed":2,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":769.0,"alternative_value":699.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-70.0},{"seed":3,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":690.0,"alternative_value":646.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-44.0},{"seed":4,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":793.0,"alternative_value":684.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-109.0},{"seed":5,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":674.0,"alternative_value":628.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-46.0},{"seed":6,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":849.0,"alternative_value":781.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-68.0},{"seed":7,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":756.0,"alternative_value":710.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-46.0},{"seed":8,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":630.0,"alternative_value":576.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-54.0},{"seed":9,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":790.0,"alternative_value":732.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-58.0},{"seed":10,"baseline":"batch_seed","alternative":"batch_savings","quantity":"distance_m","status":"ok","baseline_value":827.0,"alternative_value":729.0,"alternative_minus_baseline":-98.0},{"seed":1,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":356.66666666666623,"alternative_value":327.16666666666663,"alternative_minus_baseline":-29.499999999999602},{"seed":2,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":333.6666666666663,"alternative_value":310.3333333333333,"alternative_minus_baseline":-23.333333333332973},{"seed":3,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":336.16666666666646,"alternative_value":336.16666666666646,"alternative_minus_baseline":0.0},{"seed":4,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":324.1666666666665,"alternative_value":324.1666666666665,"alternative_minus_baseline":0.0},{"seed":5,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":338.3333333333329,"alternative_value":306.66666666666674,"alternative_minus_baseline":-31.666666666666174},{"seed":6,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":350.3333333333328,"alternative_value":339.4999999999998,"alternative_minus_baseline":-10.83333333333303},{"seed":7,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":339.16666666666646,"alternative_value":326.6666666666666,"alternative_minus_baseline":-12.499999999999886},{"seed":8,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":297.8333333333333,"alternative_value":297.8333333333333,"alternative_minus_baseline":0.0},{"seed":9,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":351.9999999999998,"alternative_value":325.6666666666665,"alternative_minus_baseline":-26.333333333333258},{"seed":10,"baseline":"schedule_list","alternative":"schedule_lpt","quantity":"makespan_s","status":"ok","baseline_value":350.83333333333303,"alternative_value":331.1666666666666,"alternative_minus_baseline":-19.66666666666646}],"run_environment":{"python":"3.11.17","platform":"Linux-6.17.0-1022-azure-x86_64-with-glibc2.39","runtime_scope":"Policy wall-clock seconds, cold graph-path cache; fixed-tour scheduling excludes tour construction."},"case":{"case_version":"wh-orderpicking.v1","warehouse":{"num_aisles":10,"slots_per_side":15,"aisle_length_m":15.0,"aisle_spacing_m":3.0,"slot_pitch_m":1.0,"io_node":"F6"},"parameters":{"capacity":20,"walk_speed_mps":1.2,"pick_seconds_per_item":3.0,"picker_count":3},"generator":{"implementation":"random.Random(seed)","order_count":30,"max_items":6,"sequence":"For each order, randint(1,6), then sample unique faces in aisle-position-side order.","face_order":["A1_L_01","A1_R_01","A1_L_02","A1_R_02","A1_L_03","A1_R_03","A1_L_04","A1_R_04","A1_L_05","A1_R_05","A1_L_06","A1_R_06","A1_L_07","A1_R_07","A1_L_08","A1_R_08","A1_L_09","A1_R_09","A1_L_10","A1_R_10","A1_L_11","A1_R_11","A1_L_12","A1_R_12","A1_L_13","A1_R_13","A1_L_14","A1_R_14","A1_L_15","A1_R_15","A2_L_01","A2_R_01","A2_L_02","A2_R_02","A2_L_03","A2_R_03","A2_L_04","A2_R_04","A2_L_05","A2_R_05","A2_L_06","A2_R_06","A2_L_07","A2_R_07","A2_L_08","A2_R_08","A2_L_09","A2_R_09","A2_L_10","A2_R_10","A2_L_11","A2_R_11","A2_L_12","A2_R_12","A2_L_13","A2_R_13","A2_L_14","A2_R_14","A2_L_15","A2_R_15","A3_L_01","A3_R_01","A3_L_02","A3_R_02","A3_L_03","A3_R_03","A3_L_04","A3_R_04","A3_L_05","A3_R_05","A3_L_06","A3_R_06","A3_L_07","A3_R_07","A3_L_08","A3_R_08","A3_L_09","A3_R_09","A3_L_10","A3_R_10","A3_L_11","A3_R_11","A3_L_12","A3_R_12","A3_L_13","A3_R_13","A3_L_14","A3_R_14","A3_L_15","A3_R_15","A4_L_01","A4_R_01","A4_L_02","A4_R_02","A4_L_03","A4_R_03","A4_L_04","A4_R_04","A4_L_05","A4_R_05","A4_L_06","A4_R_06","A4_L_07","A4_R_07","A4_L_08","A4_R_08","A4_L_09","A4_R_09","A4_L_10","A4_R_10","A4_L_11","A4_R_11","A4_L_12","A4_R_12","A4_L_13","A4_R_13","A4_L_14","A4_R_14","A4_L_15","A4_R_15","A5_L_01","A5_R_01","A5_L_02","A5_R_02","A5_L_03","A5_R_03","A5_L_04","A5_R_04","A5_L_05","A5_R_05","A5_L_06","A5_R_06","A5_L_07","A5_R_07","A5_L_08","A5_R_08","A5_L_09","A5_R_09","A5_L_10","A5_R_10","A5_L_11","A5_R_11","A5_L_12","A5_R_12","A5_L_13","A5_R_13","A5_L_14","A5_R_14","A5_L_15","A5_R_15","A6_L_01","A6_R_01","A6_L_02","A6_R_02","A6_L_03","A6_R_03","A6_L_04","A6_R_04","A6_L_05","A6_R_05","A6_L_06","A6_R_06","A6_L_07","A6_R_07","A6_L_08","A6_R_08","A6_L_09","A6_R_09","A6_L_10","A6_R_10","A6_L_11","A6_R_11","A6_L_12","A6_R_12","A6_L_13","A6_R_13","A6_L_14","A6_R_14","A6_L_15","A6_R_15","A7_L_01","A7_R_01","A7_L_02","A7_R_02","A7_L_03","A7_R_03","A7_L_04","A7_R_04","A7_L_05","A7_R_05","A7_L_06","A7_R_06","A7_L_07","A7_R_07","A7_L_08","A7_R_08","A7_L_09","A7_R_09","A7_L_10","A7_R_10","A7_L_11","A7_R_11","A7_L_12","A7_R_12","A7_L_13","A7_R_13","A7_L_14","A7_R_14","A7_L_15","A7_R_15","A8_L_01","A8_R_01","A8_L_02","A8_R_02","A8_L_03","A8_R_03","A8_L_04","A8_R_04","A8_L_05","A8_R_05","A8_L_06","A8_R_06","A8_L_07","A8_R_07","A8_L_08","A8_R_08","A8_L_09","A8_R_09","A8_L_10","A8_R_10","A8_L_11","A8_R_11","A8_L_12","A8_R_12","A8_L_13","A8_R_13","A8_L_14","A8_R_14","A8_L_15","A8_R_15","A9_L_01","A9_R_01","A9_L_02","A9_R_02","A9_L_03","A9_R_03","A9_L_04","A9_R_04","A9_L_05","A9_R_05","A9_L_06","A9_R_06","A9_L_07","A9_R_07","A9_L_08","A9_R_08","A9_L_09","A9_R_09","A9_L_10","A9_R_10","A9_L_11","A9_R_11","A9_L_12","A9_R_12","A9_L_13","A9_R_13","A9_L_14","A9_R_14","A9_L_15","A9_R_15","A10_L_01","A10_R_01","A10_L_02","A10_R_02","A10_L_03","A10_R_03","A10_L_04","A10_R_04","A10_L_05","A10_R_05","A10_L_06","A10_R_06","A10_L_07","A10_R_07","A10_L_08","A10_R_08","A10_L_09","A10_R_09","A10_L_10","A10_R_10","A10_L_11","A10_R_11","A10_L_12","A10_R_12","A10_L_13","A10_R_13","A10_L_14","A10_R_14","A10_L_15","A10_R_15"],"seeds":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10]},"historical_equivalence":false},"failed":0}